How to Choose the Right Song for Your First Recording Session

Oct 29, 2026 | Behind the Scenes

You’re choosing a song for your first recording session, and there’s plenty to look forward to. You’re picturing the microphone, the headphones and that moment when you hear your own finished recording.

Then somebody asks, “What are you going to sing?”

Suddenly, every song you’ve ever loved has disappeared from your head. Apart from one advertising jingle, which probably isn’t what you had in mind.

I’m Paul, and I help singers record their favourite songs at Audio Sorcery Recording Studios, home of recording.gifts near Tunbridge Wells. If you’re wondering what to choose for your first session, here’s my advice.

Start with a song you love

It sounds obvious, but it’s easy to choose something because you think it will be impressive.

You don’t need the biggest ballad, the fastest lyrics or the longest note in recorded history. A song you enjoy singing is a lovely place to start.

Perhaps it reminds you of someone special. Perhaps it’s been your favourite for years. Or perhaps it simply makes you turn the volume up whenever it comes on.

That connection gives you something to bring to the performance. And you’ll be spending a little time with this song, so it helps if you’re still fond of it after the third chorus.

Give the whole song a try

Most of us know our favourite chorus rather better than we know verse two.

Before settling on your choice, sing the song all the way through. Check the quieter verses as well as the big finish. Are the low notes comfortable? Can you manage the higher sections without pushing? Is there a particularly speedy bit where the words all seem to arrive together?

You’re looking for something that feels enjoyable and reasonably comfortable throughout.

If one phrase keeps causing trouble, don’t immediately abandon a song you love. Make a note of it and ask me about it before your visit.

You don’t have to sound like the original singer

You can love an Adele song without arriving with Adele’s voice.

Listening to the original is useful for learning the melody and timing, but your recording is a chance to hear your voice singing it.

You might naturally sing a phrase more gently or bring a different feeling to the words. That’s part of what makes the result yours.

There’s no impersonation round. Nobody’s waiting outside with a scorecard.

Check the backing track before you get too attached

Once you have a few ideas, have a look through our backing-track library.

Check the artist and version carefully. A live arrangement, a shortened radio version and the album recording can have different introductions, endings or extra choruses. Those little differences become surprisingly noticeable when you’re waiting for your cue.

The library search doesn’t play the tracks, but you can look for a matching karaoke version on YouTube or Spotify to help you rehearse.

And if you can’t find your favourite in our list, please ask. We may still have it available.

What if the song is a little too high?

Sometimes you love a song, but the original singer appears to have put the chorus on a shelf you can’t quite reach.

We can change the key of backing tracks, although larger changes can affect the playback quality. It’s worth discussing this with me in advance so we can work out what suits your voice and the track.

You don’t need to know the technical language. “I love this one, but the chorus feels too high” is a perfectly useful place to start.

The control room at Audio Sorcery Recording Studios
I’ll look after the recording side. You can concentrate on enjoying the song.

Practise without the original singer helping out

Singing along to the original recording is great fun. It can also hide how much the artist is helping you remember the tune, the words and where to come in.

Try a few run-throughs with a karaoke backing track. Listen for the introduction, the gaps between lines and any places where the timing catches you out.

You can make notes on your lyrics: “wait here”, “breathe”, or “chorus again”. They don’t need to look elegant. They just need to make sense to you.

Bring printed lyrics or have them ready on a tablet if that helps. This is a recording experience, not a memory test.

You’ll find more practical tips on our preparation page.

Recording more than one song? Give yourself some variety

If your experience includes several songs, think about choosing a mixture.

A gentle favourite and something more upbeat can give you two different performances to enjoy afterwards. You might also like to begin with the song you feel most comfortable singing, then move on once you’ve settled into the headphones.

Check the song allowance for your Singer experience and let us know your choices in advance. Familiarity with your songs helps us make the most of your session.

A short list of favourites is useful. A spreadsheet containing your entire musical history may require a longer discussion.

You don’t need to arrive with a perfect performance

A little preparation makes the day easier, but you don’t have to get every word and note right before you walk through the door.

We can record several takes, revisit a tricky phrase and bring the best parts together. I’ll guide you through the process and help you settle in.

If you’d like to picture the day before you arrive, have a read of what happens during a recording studio experience.

The aim is to choose a song you’ll enjoy working on and feel pleased to hear afterwards. It doesn’t have to be the song you think somebody else would choose for you.

Still deciding between two favourites?

Get in touch and tell me what you’re considering. Let me know if there’s anything worrying you, whether that’s a high note, a backing-track version or simply deciding where to start.

And if you’re still at the “I’d love to do that one day” stage, explore our Singer recording experiences.

That favourite song has had plenty of rehearsals in the kitchen.

Perhaps it’s time to give it a proper microphone.

Paul — Audio Sorcery Recording Studios / recording.gifts